Formal and informal institutions for public-private partnership functioning: perspectives form economic theory
Макаров И.Н.1, Широкова О.В.1, Колесников В.В.1
1 Финансовый университет при Правительстве Российской Федерации (Липецкий филиал)
Download PDF | Downloads: 3
Journal paper
Russian Journal of Entrepreneurship *
Volume 19, Number 1 (January 2018)
* Этот журнал не выпускается в Первом экономическом издательстве
Please, cite as:
Makarov I.N., Shirokova O.V., Kolesnikov V.V. Formalnye i neformalnye instituty funktsionirovaniya gosudarstvenno-chastnogo partnerstva: vzglyad s pozitsii ekonomicheskoy teorii // Rossiyskoe predprinimatelstvo. – 2018. – Tom 19. – № 1. – S. 77-98. – doi: 10.18334/rp.19.1.38755.
Abstract:
The article is devoted to theoretical analysis of institutional problems arising in the process of developing and implementing public-private partnership projects related to underdevelopment of the domestic institutional field, including its formal component. The article is aimed at the study of interaction of institutions and institutional environments in relation to the process of public-private partnership from the economic theory perspective. As a working hypothesis we suggest that the impact of such components as the interests of financial and industrial elite, the level of trust in the society, the culture of contracts and the development of civil society have a significant impact on the specifics of the formation and implementation of partnerships.
Keywords: institutional environment, institution, public private partnership; interests, legitimacy, theoretical analysis
JEL-classification: L32, A10, A19
References:
(2000). Public Private partnerships: the governments approach L.: The Stationery Office.
Charakhchyan K.K. (2005). Gosudarstvennoe regulirovanie rynochnoy ekonomiki: institutsionalnye aspekty [State regulation of market economy: institutional aspects] Voronezh: Izdatelstvo «Nauchnaya kniga». (in Russian).
Dzarasov S. (2008). Postkeynsianstvo i innovatsionnaya model razvitiya [Post Keynesian and innovative development model]. The Economist. (4). 67-77. (in Russian).
Ermolova K.A. (2017). Problematika razvitiya gosudarstvenno-chastnogo partnerstva v kommunalnoy infrastrukture Rossii (na materialakh Lipetskoy oblasti) [Public-private partnership development in public infrastructure of Russia (on input of the Lipetsk region)]. Russian Journal of Entrepreneurship. 18 (19). 2823-2832. (in Russian).
Galperin V.M. (1995). Teoriya firmy [Theory of the firm] SPb.: Ekonomicheskaya shkola. (in Russian).
Hamilton W., Seligman E, Johnson A. (1932). Institution Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences. (8). 84.
Khayek F.A. (1992). Pagubnaya samonadeyannost [Pernicious arrogance] M.: Novosti. (in Russian).
Khayek F.A. (1999). Poznanie, konkurentsiya i svoboda: Antologiya sochineniy [Cognition, Competition and Freedom: An Anthology of Works] SPb.: Pnevma. (in Russian).
Khodzhson Dzh. (2003). Ekonomicheskaya teoriya i instituty: Manifest sovremennoy institutsionalnoy ekonomicheskoy teorii [Economics and Institutions: A Manifesto for a Modern Institutional Economics. ] M.: Delo. (in Russian).
Khodzhson Dzh. (2000). Privychki, pravila i ekonomicheskoe povedenie [Habits, rules and economic behavior]. Voprosy Ekonomiki. (1). 39-55. (in Russian).
Kolesnikov V.V., Koryakina T.V., Makarov I.N. (2017). Proektnoe finansirovanie i gosudarstvenno-chastnoe partnerstvo v regionakh Rossii: institutsionalnye i upravlencheskie problemy [Project financing and public-private partnership in Russian regions: institutional and management issues]. Russian Journal of Entrepreneurship. 18 (14). 2129-2142. (in Russian). doi: 10.18334/rp.18.14.38135.
Kornai Ya. (2012). Razmyshleniya o kapitalizme [Reflections on capitalism] M.: Izdatelstvo Instituta Gaydara. (in Russian).
Kornai Ya. (2003). Chestnost i doverie v perekhodnoy ekonomike [Honesty and trust in a transitional economy]. Voprosy Ekonomiki. (9). 4-17. (in Russian).
Kulikov V.G. (2008). Analiz zarubezhnogo opyta vzaimodeystviya gosudarstvennyh i predprinimatelskikh struktur [Analysis of foreign experience of interaction between the state and business structures]. Economic sciences. (2(39)). 38-41. (in Russian).
Kushlin V.I. (2002). Gosudarstvennoe regulirovanie rynochnoy ekonomiki [State regulation of market economy] M.: Izdatelstvo RAGS. (in Russian).
Kuzminov Ya., Radaev V., Yakovlev A., Yasin E. (2005). Instituty: ot zaimstvovaniya k vyraschivaniyu [Institutions: from borrowing to cultivation]. Voprosy Ekonomiki. (5). 5-27. (in Russian).
Lister D. (2000). PUK to back projects worth 20bn Time.
Makarov I.N. (2009). Sovremennaya ekonomika: regulirovanie i partnerstvo [Modern economy: regulation and partnership]. Russian Journal of Entrepreneurship. 10 (8). 22-27. (in Russian).
Makarov I.N. (2009). Struktura i evolyutsiya institutsionalnoy sredy gosudarstvenno-chastnogo partnerstva [Structure and evolution of the institutional environment of public-private partnership]. Russian Journal of Entrepreneurship. 10 (3). 96-100. (in Russian).
Makarov I.N. (2011). Neobkhodimost sovershenstvovaniya institutsionalnoy sredy gosudarstvenno-chastnogo partnerstva v usloviyakh Rossii [The need to improve institutional environment of public-private partnership in the conditions of Russia]. Russian Journal of Entrepreneurship. 12 (7). 74-79. (in Russian).
Manko N.N. (2012). Issledovanie spetsifiki otnosheniy sobstvennosti v proektakh gosudarstvenno-chastnogo partnerstva [Study of the Specifics of Ownership Relations in the Public-Private Partnership Projects]. Russian Journal of Entrepreneurship. 13 (11). 16-21. (in Russian).
Nort D. (1997). Instituty, institutsionalnye izmeneniya i funktsionirovanie ekonomiki [Institutions, institutional changes and economic functioning ] M.: Fond ekonomicheskoy knigi «Nachala». (in Russian).
Petrakov N. (2008). Ukreplenie prav sobstvennosti: transformirovat ne razrushaya [Strengthening property rights: transform without destroying]. Voprosy Ekonomiki. (3). 64-67. (in Russian).
Semenova N.N., Ermoshina T.V. (2017). Finansirovanie investitsionnyh proektov na osnove mekhanizma gosudarstvenno-chastnogo partnerstva [Financing of investment projects on the basis of the public-private partnership mechanism]. Russian Journal of Entrepreneurship. 18 (10). 1567-1578. (in Russian). doi: 10.18334/rp.18.10.37954.
Shastitko A., Radchenko T. (2008). Mekhanizmy korporativnogo upravleniya: Mesto aktsionernyh soglasheniy [Mechanisms of corporate governance: the place of shareholders agreements]. Voprosy Ekonomiki. (10). 49-61. (in Russian).
Shastitko A.E. (1998). Neoinstitutsionalnaya ekonomicheskaya teoriya [Neoinstitutional economic theory] M.: TEIS. (in Russian).
Shastitko A.E. (2002). Novaya institutsionalnaya ekonomicheskaya teoriya [The new institutional economic theory] M.: TEIS. (in Russian).
Shastitko A.E. (2007). Ekonomicheskaya teoriya organizatsiy [The economic theory of organizations] M.: INFRA-M. (in Russian).
Shastitko A.E. (2004). Reforma antimonopolnogo regulirovaniya v Rossii: povestka dnya i dizayn diskussii [The reform of antitrust regulation in Russia: the agenda and discussion design ]. Voprosy Ekonomiki. (3). 140-148. (in Russian).
Uilyamson O.I. (1996). Ekonomicheskie instituty kapitalizma: Firmy, rynki, «otnoshencheskaya» kontraktatsiya [Economic institutions of capitalism: Firms, markets, "relative" contracting] SPb.: Lenizdat. (in Russian).
Varnavskiy V.G. (2005). Gosudarstvenno-chastnoe partnerstvo v Evrope [Public-private partnership in Europe]. Modern Europe. (2(22)). 62-71. (in Russian).
Vilisov M.V., Sulakshin S.S., Khrustaleva E.A. (2005). Gosudarstvenno-chastnoe partnerstvo v dorozhnoy sfere [Public-private partnership in the road sector] M.: Nauchnyy ekspert. (in Russian).
Yavlinskiy G. (2007). Neobkhodimost i sposoby legitimatsii krupnoy chastnoy sobstvennosti v Rossii: postanovka problemy [Necessity and ways of legitimizing large private property in Russia: posing a problem]. Voprosy Ekonomiki. (9). 4-26. (in Russian).
Charakhchyan K.K. (2005). Gosudarstvennoe regulirovanie rynochnoy ekonomiki: institutsionalnye aspekty [State regulation of market economy: institutional aspects] Voronezh: Izdatelstvo «Nauchnaya kniga». (in Russian).
Dzarasov S. (2008). Postkeynsianstvo i innovatsionnaya model razvitiya [Post Keynesian and innovative development model]. The Economist. (4). 67-77. (in Russian).
Ermolova K.A. (2017). Problematika razvitiya gosudarstvenno-chastnogo partnerstva v kommunalnoy infrastrukture Rossii (na materialakh Lipetskoy oblasti) [Public-private partnership development in public infrastructure of Russia (on input of the Lipetsk region)]. Russian Journal of Entrepreneurship. 18 (19). 2823-2832. (in Russian).
Galperin V.M. (1995). Teoriya firmy [Theory of the firm] SPb.: Ekonomicheskaya shkola. (in Russian).
Hamilton W., Seligman E, Johnson A. (1932). Institution Encyclopedia of the Social Sciences. (8). 84.
Khayek F.A. (1992). Pagubnaya samonadeyannost [Pernicious arrogance] M.: Novosti. (in Russian).
Khayek F.A. (1999). Poznanie, konkurentsiya i svoboda: Antologiya sochineniy [Cognition, Competition and Freedom: An Anthology of Works] SPb.: Pnevma. (in Russian).
Khodzhson Dzh. (2003). Ekonomicheskaya teoriya i instituty: Manifest sovremennoy institutsionalnoy ekonomicheskoy teorii [Economics and Institutions: A Manifesto for a Modern Institutional Economics. ] M.: Delo. (in Russian).
Khodzhson Dzh. (2000). Privychki, pravila i ekonomicheskoe povedenie [Habits, rules and economic behavior]. Voprosy Ekonomiki. (1). 39-55. (in Russian).
Kolesnikov V.V., Koryakina T.V., Makarov I.N. (2017). Proektnoe finansirovanie i gosudarstvenno-chastnoe partnerstvo v regionakh Rossii: institutsionalnye i upravlencheskie problemy [Project financing and public-private partnership in Russian regions: institutional and management issues]. Russian Journal of Entrepreneurship. 18 (14). 2129-2142. (in Russian). doi: 10.18334/rp.18.14.38135.
Kornai Ya. (2012). Razmyshleniya o kapitalizme [Reflections on capitalism] M.: Izdatelstvo Instituta Gaydara. (in Russian).
Kornai Ya. (2003). Chestnost i doverie v perekhodnoy ekonomike [Honesty and trust in a transitional economy]. Voprosy Ekonomiki. (9). 4-17. (in Russian).
Kulikov V.G. (2008). Analiz zarubezhnogo opyta vzaimodeystviya gosudarstvennyh i predprinimatelskikh struktur [Analysis of foreign experience of interaction between the state and business structures]. Economic sciences. (2(39)). 38-41. (in Russian).
Kushlin V.I. (2002). Gosudarstvennoe regulirovanie rynochnoy ekonomiki [State regulation of market economy] M.: Izdatelstvo RAGS. (in Russian).
Kuzminov Ya., Radaev V., Yakovlev A., Yasin E. (2005). Instituty: ot zaimstvovaniya k vyraschivaniyu [Institutions: from borrowing to cultivation]. Voprosy Ekonomiki. (5). 5-27. (in Russian).
Lister D. (2000). PUK to back projects worth 20bn Time.
Makarov I.N. (2009). Sovremennaya ekonomika: regulirovanie i partnerstvo [Modern economy: regulation and partnership]. Russian Journal of Entrepreneurship. 10 (8). 22-27. (in Russian).
Makarov I.N. (2009). Struktura i evolyutsiya institutsionalnoy sredy gosudarstvenno-chastnogo partnerstva [Structure and evolution of the institutional environment of public-private partnership]. Russian Journal of Entrepreneurship. 10 (3). 96-100. (in Russian).
Makarov I.N. (2011). Neobkhodimost sovershenstvovaniya institutsionalnoy sredy gosudarstvenno-chastnogo partnerstva v usloviyakh Rossii [The need to improve institutional environment of public-private partnership in the conditions of Russia]. Russian Journal of Entrepreneurship. 12 (7). 74-79. (in Russian).
Manko N.N. (2012). Issledovanie spetsifiki otnosheniy sobstvennosti v proektakh gosudarstvenno-chastnogo partnerstva [Study of the Specifics of Ownership Relations in the Public-Private Partnership Projects]. Russian Journal of Entrepreneurship. 13 (11). 16-21. (in Russian).
Nort D. (1997). Instituty, institutsionalnye izmeneniya i funktsionirovanie ekonomiki [Institutions, institutional changes and economic functioning ] M.: Fond ekonomicheskoy knigi «Nachala». (in Russian).
Petrakov N. (2008). Ukreplenie prav sobstvennosti: transformirovat ne razrushaya [Strengthening property rights: transform without destroying]. Voprosy Ekonomiki. (3). 64-67. (in Russian).
Semenova N.N., Ermoshina T.V. (2017). Finansirovanie investitsionnyh proektov na osnove mekhanizma gosudarstvenno-chastnogo partnerstva [Financing of investment projects on the basis of the public-private partnership mechanism]. Russian Journal of Entrepreneurship. 18 (10). 1567-1578. (in Russian). doi: 10.18334/rp.18.10.37954.
Shastitko A., Radchenko T. (2008). Mekhanizmy korporativnogo upravleniya: Mesto aktsionernyh soglasheniy [Mechanisms of corporate governance: the place of shareholders agreements]. Voprosy Ekonomiki. (10). 49-61. (in Russian).
Shastitko A.E. (1998). Neoinstitutsionalnaya ekonomicheskaya teoriya [Neoinstitutional economic theory] M.: TEIS. (in Russian).
Shastitko A.E. (2002). Novaya institutsionalnaya ekonomicheskaya teoriya [The new institutional economic theory] M.: TEIS. (in Russian).
Shastitko A.E. (2007). Ekonomicheskaya teoriya organizatsiy [The economic theory of organizations] M.: INFRA-M. (in Russian).
Shastitko A.E. (2004). Reforma antimonopolnogo regulirovaniya v Rossii: povestka dnya i dizayn diskussii [The reform of antitrust regulation in Russia: the agenda and discussion design ]. Voprosy Ekonomiki. (3). 140-148. (in Russian).
Uilyamson O.I. (1996). Ekonomicheskie instituty kapitalizma: Firmy, rynki, «otnoshencheskaya» kontraktatsiya [Economic institutions of capitalism: Firms, markets, "relative" contracting] SPb.: Lenizdat. (in Russian).
Varnavskiy V.G. (2005). Gosudarstvenno-chastnoe partnerstvo v Evrope [Public-private partnership in Europe]. Modern Europe. (2(22)). 62-71. (in Russian).
Vilisov M.V., Sulakshin S.S., Khrustaleva E.A. (2005). Gosudarstvenno-chastnoe partnerstvo v dorozhnoy sfere [Public-private partnership in the road sector] M.: Nauchnyy ekspert. (in Russian).
Yavlinskiy G. (2007). Neobkhodimost i sposoby legitimatsii krupnoy chastnoy sobstvennosti v Rossii: postanovka problemy [Necessity and ways of legitimizing large private property in Russia: posing a problem]. Voprosy Ekonomiki. (9). 4-26. (in Russian).
Страница обновлена: 20.04.2024 в 14:46:20